We want our saplings to grow into mighty Oaks. Some into GM's, and the others to stand tall in a globalised world. To be men/women of worth, of substance, making valuable contributions. Not parasites, weak people that run around with a begging bowl that only know how to prey on the weak.
Is that what you want for your child? Is that the end in sight?
If it is, there is one principle we need to embrace. They do as we do, they do not do as we say.
So, what do we have now? In the chess world. We hear people have tried for many many years to change the system. None have succeeded. Money have been spent, persuasion tried, opportunities offered and it's still the same. So many just sit down now and say we are helpless and some have joined that system.
A circle of negativity. How do we change that? If you go back to my personal story, read here, I hope I've shown that one positive result can take us far.
It brings back hope and positive energy. Just one.
So forget about changing MCF. If you try, they will suck your energy, you will use 1000 pounds of energy to produce one ounce of work. Over time you will be exhausted and nothing will have changed.
Think, do we really need them? What is the fear? That they will fix the matches? That they will not submit your results. That they will victimise your child? That they will victimise you?
They are using your fears against you. And if they succeed, you would have lost all you wanted to get out of chess. I remember telling Mark, if you allow them to intimidate you, you will never be a GM or for that matter a person of substance.
So look again, can MCF really do what you think they can do? The threats lie beneath the surface. They smile and try to look reasonable on the surface. Why? It's because nowadays with the blogs, they cannot do like they did before. News spread like wild fire today. So they have adapted. Your fears may not be grounded in reality today.
So I say, let them be. We focus on getting results. Achievable results. We stop barking up the wrong tree.
And we keep in our memory one major point. We need a safe nursery to incubate our saplings. Then they can grow into tall oaks. Then they can fend for themselves one day. When we are no longer around or even when we are around but older.
Remember that, dont compromise. Do it for the children. They cant stand on their own yet. For now we need to stand for them. Will you do it?
First GM is formulating a plan that we hope will have the elements that will achieve real results. The sight is a little further; beyond our shores. Why? Because the first GM can only come when we can compete Internationally. More work needs to be done still but it is coming.
Sunday, July 4, 2010
Saturday, July 3, 2010
The nature of parenthood
Parents by nature are protective of their kids. They want their kids to do well. When I was in the UK, I was shocked when I found out that many leave their homes at the age of 18. And from what I see of the Americans, they have little control of their kids. But on the whole, they are better risk takers because they are allowed to experiment.
We Asians are more controlling. Sometimes stiffling. But we all want the best for our kids. And we try to do our best.
But what do we really want underneath all these different methods of child raising?
In my case, I want my kid to learn how to compete as I want him to be able to stand tall when he faces the outside world eventually. I dont want him to be bullied, taken advantage of. I want him to learn how to take measured risks, have good judgement, learn how to tell who the predators are in all their sophisticated guises these days. They dont bare their teeths anymore nowadays, they come bearing sweets. Internet and TV?
I also want him to learn how to partner, how to find the right partners. We are heading for a globalised world, like it or not.
In chess, I found a useful tool to learn about healthy competition and genuine friendship, in my internet business he learns about partnerships.
Is that what you want too? Is that why you brought your kids into chess? Is that what you are getting out of it? Was it the plan to see their fighting spirits crushed out of them? Was it the plan for them to see us sitting down defeated and say there is nothing I can do? Is that the way to prepare them to face a globalised world? They will be facing it, like it or not. Not all will become GM's but there is value if they are lead by example. If we want our kids to stand tall, then parents, you are part of the system too, so are the trainers etc. etc. The kids are watching, learning to do as we do.
We Asians are more controlling. Sometimes stiffling. But we all want the best for our kids. And we try to do our best.
But what do we really want underneath all these different methods of child raising?
In my case, I want my kid to learn how to compete as I want him to be able to stand tall when he faces the outside world eventually. I dont want him to be bullied, taken advantage of. I want him to learn how to take measured risks, have good judgement, learn how to tell who the predators are in all their sophisticated guises these days. They dont bare their teeths anymore nowadays, they come bearing sweets. Internet and TV?
I also want him to learn how to partner, how to find the right partners. We are heading for a globalised world, like it or not.
In chess, I found a useful tool to learn about healthy competition and genuine friendship, in my internet business he learns about partnerships.
Is that what you want too? Is that why you brought your kids into chess? Is that what you are getting out of it? Was it the plan to see their fighting spirits crushed out of them? Was it the plan for them to see us sitting down defeated and say there is nothing I can do? Is that the way to prepare them to face a globalised world? They will be facing it, like it or not. Not all will become GM's but there is value if they are lead by example. If we want our kids to stand tall, then parents, you are part of the system too, so are the trainers etc. etc. The kids are watching, learning to do as we do.
Saturday night after dinner musings
All my life, no matter where I sat on the totem pole, I've always had this philosophy. If the cleaner in the office says something that makes sense, I listen. And if a Dato, a Tan Sri or a GM says something that doesnt make sense, I reject.
To me it's always been the value of the content, the value of the contribution.
Then I joined PICA, and I heard so many self congratulatory and insincere flattery, I wondered if they actually believe what they were saying.
I now wonder if that is why when a known strong player sits opposite someone else, the other guy crumbles. Maybe they respect the title too much and then forget how to think. Just musing while my coffee is brewing.
To me it's always been the value of the content, the value of the contribution.
Then I joined PICA, and I heard so many self congratulatory and insincere flattery, I wondered if they actually believe what they were saying.
I now wonder if that is why when a known strong player sits opposite someone else, the other guy crumbles. Maybe they respect the title too much and then forget how to think. Just musing while my coffee is brewing.
What is a champion?
From the comments of the trainers on this blog, I dont think they see the bigger picture. It is an obvious and easy conclusion to say that the technically stronger player will win some games at a tournament.
But let us look further. Let us look at what the final objective should be.
Let me use an example here.
In a lower rated tournament, the technically stronger players will just beat half the field with no pressure. Say 9 rounds. That is 41/2 points. Then he may beat one after a little tension. Say it takes 7 points to be champion. He needs 11/2 more points. Now what do you think are the factors that will give him those points?
Confidence? Good judgement? Concentration? Remember he is playing the game, not the coach. Would how he view things, whether negatively or positively have a bearing on outcome? If he cannot see the possibilities because he is anxious, fearful, angry, frightened or just plain tired or jaded. Would that affect the outcome?
Now let us see even further, he goes for higher rated tournaments, the pressure mounts. There are no more easy games. What do you think happens at ever increasing pressure? We are nearing technical parity. What will carry the day?
If he cannot look at the board clearly. (Is there a correlation to if he cannot even read a posting with understanding, with comprehension?)
If he cannot evaluate the position correctly. (Is there a correlation to how he sees himself in the larger scheme of things, like partnering, training?)
You cannot learn to fight on the board only. The Champion is distinguished by having internalised all the qualities it takes to be Champion. And that is why there is so few of them. That is why they are special. That is what it takes to be GM.
But even a Champion can be crushed when they are young. By trainers that need to prove they are superior to the young ones. By needing the respect of the young minds, they try to bring them down to their beaten state, instead of grooming them. These are observable phenomenons, if you care, dare to look. It is happening everyday all around us. Is this a clue to why we do not do well after U12?
Over time do we not crush our Champions. Or Champions to be had they been nurtured; had we been more vigilant to protect their fighting spirit in the course of giving them technical knowledge. Do I have a point here?
We need to plan with the end in sight. If this is what we want, what are we doing wrong? As a VP from Thailand Chess Association said to me in Subic Bay, technical we can buy, its no big thing. But how do we instil fighting spirit in our players?
But let us look further. Let us look at what the final objective should be.
Let me use an example here.
In a lower rated tournament, the technically stronger players will just beat half the field with no pressure. Say 9 rounds. That is 41/2 points. Then he may beat one after a little tension. Say it takes 7 points to be champion. He needs 11/2 more points. Now what do you think are the factors that will give him those points?
Confidence? Good judgement? Concentration? Remember he is playing the game, not the coach. Would how he view things, whether negatively or positively have a bearing on outcome? If he cannot see the possibilities because he is anxious, fearful, angry, frightened or just plain tired or jaded. Would that affect the outcome?
Now let us see even further, he goes for higher rated tournaments, the pressure mounts. There are no more easy games. What do you think happens at ever increasing pressure? We are nearing technical parity. What will carry the day?
If he cannot look at the board clearly. (Is there a correlation to if he cannot even read a posting with understanding, with comprehension?)
If he cannot evaluate the position correctly. (Is there a correlation to how he sees himself in the larger scheme of things, like partnering, training?)
You cannot learn to fight on the board only. The Champion is distinguished by having internalised all the qualities it takes to be Champion. And that is why there is so few of them. That is why they are special. That is what it takes to be GM.
But even a Champion can be crushed when they are young. By trainers that need to prove they are superior to the young ones. By needing the respect of the young minds, they try to bring them down to their beaten state, instead of grooming them. These are observable phenomenons, if you care, dare to look. It is happening everyday all around us. Is this a clue to why we do not do well after U12?
Over time do we not crush our Champions. Or Champions to be had they been nurtured; had we been more vigilant to protect their fighting spirit in the course of giving them technical knowledge. Do I have a point here?
We need to plan with the end in sight. If this is what we want, what are we doing wrong? As a VP from Thailand Chess Association said to me in Subic Bay, technical we can buy, its no big thing. But how do we instil fighting spirit in our players?
Saturday morning musings
Looking back on this blog, do you see something? Do you see where most of the comments come from? When there is a chance to tear someone down, there is a flock. Where a finger is pointed to where the problem really is, silence. When a suggestion is asked for, the most substantive contribution comes from a Singaporean.
Now consider this. If we realise that it takes the efforts of many to produce the First GM and to do that we need to partner. And partnering must come from trust; Partners must carry their own load.
And we are working with people who wants to tear down at first opportunity, not give suggestions when they have the knowledge to help the team succeed. Where will this get us? I'm assuming of course that this blog has some reflection on our mindset.
Now consider this. If we realise that it takes the efforts of many to produce the First GM and to do that we need to partner. And partnering must come from trust; Partners must carry their own load.
And we are working with people who wants to tear down at first opportunity, not give suggestions when they have the knowledge to help the team succeed. Where will this get us? I'm assuming of course that this blog has some reflection on our mindset.
Mental Strength
As the players gain in knowledge, they should also be gaining in confidence. If not something is wrong. And we should look there instead of denial. To be fair to the trainers, not all is in their control. But this is. Observe carefully. Many trainers that have had their fighting spirit knocked out of them, pass on their negativity to the players. Read this.
Do you see that? Will you reflect on this and the article above or will you just quickly skim through what I just said? Actually you have shown alot of courage already if you can even read this message without panic.
Do you see that? Will you reflect on this and the article above or will you just quickly skim through what I just said? Actually you have shown alot of courage already if you can even read this message without panic.
Friday, July 2, 2010
Parents 2
Part 1.
A bigger say. Yes, but there is a caveat. Let me qualify. What I mean is that their proper expectations of MCF should be met... MCF, should regulate, set well thought out policies, partner with people who can give them results, value. In other words, get their act together. Not only jump when Dato calls.
They are beholden to all. They belong to the chess players, parents, sponsors and every other stakeholder. Not the other way around.
But let me qualify again, they also cannot cater to every whim and fancy of parents, players, trainers etc.
Why?.. because they have to carry the bigger picture. Although I have been in chess 6 years, I only started to see the bigger issues, when I first joined PICA. Dealing with sponsors, and all the many other parties is not easy, even when you have a select team. Much more difficult when all have different ideas. The needs of Academies to thrive so they can afford the services of experts, relationship with State Affiliates, other bodies like MOE etc. are all very very difficult to balance.
So I can emphatise. It is difficult. And that is why I do not begrudge them a proper pay. But only and only if they are doing the work.
Honestly as a parent, player, even trainer, you have no clue. Your perspective is too small. But you have a right all the same. You have a right to an MCF that is doing its best to get results. Chicken and the egg? We have no money and so we do the monkey business. And because of the monkey business nobody feels you should be paid.
Well, someone has to start. So unless Dato Tan suddenly decides that he will pay a decent wage to all properly working officials for say 2 years to prove yourself, I suggest that MCF, you get your act together first. Hard, when MCF demands so much of your time and the bills keep coming regularly. But people are not blind. They can see good work. Ignore the unreasonable people. They dont really matter. Get your act together and you will receive goodwill. You have blown many chances, many opportunities to get it right. Dont let failure be your legacy.
A bigger say. Yes, but there is a caveat. Let me qualify. What I mean is that their proper expectations of MCF should be met... MCF, should regulate, set well thought out policies, partner with people who can give them results, value. In other words, get their act together. Not only jump when Dato calls.
They are beholden to all. They belong to the chess players, parents, sponsors and every other stakeholder. Not the other way around.
But let me qualify again, they also cannot cater to every whim and fancy of parents, players, trainers etc.
Why?.. because they have to carry the bigger picture. Although I have been in chess 6 years, I only started to see the bigger issues, when I first joined PICA. Dealing with sponsors, and all the many other parties is not easy, even when you have a select team. Much more difficult when all have different ideas. The needs of Academies to thrive so they can afford the services of experts, relationship with State Affiliates, other bodies like MOE etc. are all very very difficult to balance.
So I can emphatise. It is difficult. And that is why I do not begrudge them a proper pay. But only and only if they are doing the work.
Honestly as a parent, player, even trainer, you have no clue. Your perspective is too small. But you have a right all the same. You have a right to an MCF that is doing its best to get results. Chicken and the egg? We have no money and so we do the monkey business. And because of the monkey business nobody feels you should be paid.
Well, someone has to start. So unless Dato Tan suddenly decides that he will pay a decent wage to all properly working officials for say 2 years to prove yourself, I suggest that MCF, you get your act together first. Hard, when MCF demands so much of your time and the bills keep coming regularly. But people are not blind. They can see good work. Ignore the unreasonable people. They dont really matter. Get your act together and you will receive goodwill. You have blown many chances, many opportunities to get it right. Dont let failure be your legacy.
The current biggest stakeholder
Parents.
Make no mistake about that. Their contribution, in my mind, far outstrips any that even Dato has contributed. Why do I say that? Well, there is no public accounting.
My estimation from my own small personal contributions compared to many others, realising that there is money to be made in chess by certain parties (from my Asean experience) and from the answer to my point blank question to Ignatius at Subic Bay....
They do make money but they tell you that they dont. Part of the fault is because our chess community believes that no one should make money from chess. And that could be the reason why some otherwise honest people have to resort to all these smoke screens to hide that fact. So the blame is partly that faulty assumption. I believe we should let them make money. It is crazy not to. Let them make it honestly. By giving value. Halal money. Not this hide in the dark kind of money where even quotations are suspect.
So if we add up all the contributions from parents, look at the 10 million that is said to have been spent by Dato, factor in that he may have profited from that investment, then I think the numbers will show that parents made the most contribution. And they asked for nothing more than for MCF to lead and produce results. And so since MCF is the beneficiary of the current biggest stakeholder, shouldnt they have a say? And maybe, just maybe, a bigger say than Dato? And not just lip service.
Who started that rumour anyway? How did it get so entrenched in chess that people are hypnotised not to see the fact that it needs money to do well in chess? I am really, really curious where it all started.
Make no mistake about that. Their contribution, in my mind, far outstrips any that even Dato has contributed. Why do I say that? Well, there is no public accounting.
My estimation from my own small personal contributions compared to many others, realising that there is money to be made in chess by certain parties (from my Asean experience) and from the answer to my point blank question to Ignatius at Subic Bay....
They do make money but they tell you that they dont. Part of the fault is because our chess community believes that no one should make money from chess. And that could be the reason why some otherwise honest people have to resort to all these smoke screens to hide that fact. So the blame is partly that faulty assumption. I believe we should let them make money. It is crazy not to. Let them make it honestly. By giving value. Halal money. Not this hide in the dark kind of money where even quotations are suspect.
So if we add up all the contributions from parents, look at the 10 million that is said to have been spent by Dato, factor in that he may have profited from that investment, then I think the numbers will show that parents made the most contribution. And they asked for nothing more than for MCF to lead and produce results. And so since MCF is the beneficiary of the current biggest stakeholder, shouldnt they have a say? And maybe, just maybe, a bigger say than Dato? And not just lip service.
Who started that rumour anyway? How did it get so entrenched in chess that people are hypnotised not to see the fact that it needs money to do well in chess? I am really, really curious where it all started.
Further to Lessons from Asean training
Given that statistic that our players do not do well after U12, it is reasonable to investigate the way we are teaching them at the onset, if a solution is to be found. A few suggestions has been brought up by John in his comment. What we must not do is find a way to blame the players and then say it's not the trainers fault.
If we look carefully, and its been mentioned many times, our players were not deficient at a young age. So there remains a possiblity that somehow the way we are teaching them does not give them the foundation to grow in the later stages.
Personally, I believe John may have a point. We need to nurture their curiousity, teach them to experiment, help them to set realistic goals, horne their judgement and understanding of the nature of risk.
One big mistake is to only look at the technical aspects. They lose because they have bad habits of last minute preparation. We teach them to look at the lines. They lose because they cannot manage their fears, we look at the lines again. They lose beacuse they have no patience, again the lines, they lose because their goal was unrealistic, back to the lines etc etc.
They say you cannot build a home with just one tool. And they also say that you can have a beautiful racing car but if the spark plugs are missing, the car wont run.
You can have the most talented player but if the fighting spirit is knocked out of them they will eventually fade.
So stop pointing the finger at the players, look at our system. Stop looking only at the technical aspects, look at where the problem truly lies. Further avoidance of this truth will only delay our own recovery.
At my lowest point in 2005, I realised this, I cannot change the internet world and make them all like me. I can only change myself. I cant even change my own son. I can only point the way and if he agrees then he must walk the road. I cannot walk it for him no matter how much I want to.
So stop looking at blaming the players. Look at yourself. Look at our support system.
If we look carefully, and its been mentioned many times, our players were not deficient at a young age. So there remains a possiblity that somehow the way we are teaching them does not give them the foundation to grow in the later stages.
Personally, I believe John may have a point. We need to nurture their curiousity, teach them to experiment, help them to set realistic goals, horne their judgement and understanding of the nature of risk.
One big mistake is to only look at the technical aspects. They lose because they have bad habits of last minute preparation. We teach them to look at the lines. They lose because they cannot manage their fears, we look at the lines again. They lose beacuse they have no patience, again the lines, they lose because their goal was unrealistic, back to the lines etc etc.
They say you cannot build a home with just one tool. And they also say that you can have a beautiful racing car but if the spark plugs are missing, the car wont run.
You can have the most talented player but if the fighting spirit is knocked out of them they will eventually fade.
So stop pointing the finger at the players, look at our system. Stop looking only at the technical aspects, look at where the problem truly lies. Further avoidance of this truth will only delay our own recovery.
At my lowest point in 2005, I realised this, I cannot change the internet world and make them all like me. I can only change myself. I cant even change my own son. I can only point the way and if he agrees then he must walk the road. I cannot walk it for him no matter how much I want to.
So stop looking at blaming the players. Look at yourself. Look at our support system.
Thursday, July 1, 2010
Ego vs results based decisions 2
Part 1.
Observe carefully, one is based on reality, the other based on delusion. Go back and read the comments on this blog and see if you can spot the ones that come from ego and the ones that are looking for results.
Hint: The ones that want results offer some suggestions to improve.
When we want results, we try to deeply understand the problem. We test out little models. We ask questions, not form hasty conclusions. With sufficient facts, we make evaluations and finally decisions towards the desired outcome.
So lets look at this problem. We know that it costs money to go overseas to play in competitions. And we know that many cannot afford it. And a few deserving cases are in need of sponsorship.
One possible solution is to allow more players to go to International competitions; those that can afford it. Use say the Singapore's model and allow all those who achieve more than 50% in select tournaments to represent the Country. After all they are paying and not MCF.
You then select certain International tournaments that have a higher chance of medals and encourage them to go there. You can even prepare them by having them go for paid training. After all these are people who can afford it.
With the medals come the sponsors. When there are a few good sponsors, you say to them, hey look, there's this one kid. The family doesnt have much money. But if you sponsor him/her then you can get milleage out of it etc. etc.
Things work in process, one step at a time. Thats just how things work.
I said earlier that ego acts in defence against admitting failure. Ergo Fear. Now you want everything at once. You want money without giving value.
Ego also doesnt want to understand and ego makes knee jerk self serving statements, actions. When ego is involved a simple thing can become very very complicated. Have you any personal experience?
So we dont have a problem that requires rocket science to solve, we have a problem that requires the leaders to manage thier fears and reduce their egos enough to get to a solution.
Observe carefully, one is based on reality, the other based on delusion. Go back and read the comments on this blog and see if you can spot the ones that come from ego and the ones that are looking for results.
Hint: The ones that want results offer some suggestions to improve.
When we want results, we try to deeply understand the problem. We test out little models. We ask questions, not form hasty conclusions. With sufficient facts, we make evaluations and finally decisions towards the desired outcome.
So lets look at this problem. We know that it costs money to go overseas to play in competitions. And we know that many cannot afford it. And a few deserving cases are in need of sponsorship.
One possible solution is to allow more players to go to International competitions; those that can afford it. Use say the Singapore's model and allow all those who achieve more than 50% in select tournaments to represent the Country. After all they are paying and not MCF.
You then select certain International tournaments that have a higher chance of medals and encourage them to go there. You can even prepare them by having them go for paid training. After all these are people who can afford it.
With the medals come the sponsors. When there are a few good sponsors, you say to them, hey look, there's this one kid. The family doesnt have much money. But if you sponsor him/her then you can get milleage out of it etc. etc.
Things work in process, one step at a time. Thats just how things work.
I said earlier that ego acts in defence against admitting failure. Ergo Fear. Now you want everything at once. You want money without giving value.
Ego also doesnt want to understand and ego makes knee jerk self serving statements, actions. When ego is involved a simple thing can become very very complicated. Have you any personal experience?
So we dont have a problem that requires rocket science to solve, we have a problem that requires the leaders to manage thier fears and reduce their egos enough to get to a solution.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



