Thursday, March 4, 2010

Train the trainer- Reply from Greg Lau

I just received a reply from Greg that the course is indeed from MCF. I hope readers will please check carefully before posting such allegations in the future. I have posted the reply here.

Time management and Malaysian time

To me mastery of chess encompasses 4 elements. One is understanding yourself, the second is understanding your opponent, the third is time management and finally the board.

Time management

As some of you know, I do business on the internet and I deal primarily with Americans and we charge by the hour. What does that mean? In our case that meant we had to learn to look at a piece of work and estimate how much time that work will take to do. That requires development and refinement of judgement. We started by looking at pieces of work that others were doing and what they were charging for the time taken and then putting ourselves through the same test. We timed ourselves. And we did that until we could perform the same task, at the same quality as the global market. And then we went one step further. We tried to do it more efficiently, more effectively. See eMasters

We even did that to our sub contractors. We evaluate them not only by their hourly rates and turn around time but also by the amount of time they spend using up our time; whether there are unnecessary wastage of our time from careless mistakes, whether they communicate in a timely manner.

This value of time, our time and other people's time is a cultivated habit. So if you have one week to complete the project you have to hustle. If you have one day, you hustle even faster but without making a mistake.

Does this sound familiar? This is chess. How many games are lost because of time trouble? How do we learn this habit to the level to produce that GM?

The time given to every player is the same all over the world, and to get that GM we have to compete in the global arena and they won't let us play Malaysian time. You can't not value time in every other area of your life and master time on the chess board.

Update on train the trainer in Perak

Just spoke to Greg on the phone. He says it's an MCF event. I invited him to clarify on the blog but he said that he can't. He said that if there are any doubts we can write to him officially and he will give a reply. On behalf of First GM Chess Academy I will do just that and keep you all apprised. I continue to want to give him the benefit of the doubt until there is positive proof otherwise because the alternative spells a very bleak future for Malaysian chess.

PS: I have to admit that I am currently suspicious of my own judgements since transfering my day to day responsibilities and coming off the online world in 2009. Every one I have met in chess talks about wanting development and obviously I have been fooled, leading to my explusion from PICA. Too many skilled wolves in sheep clothing. I do not have the skills to evaluate other than by closely examining their actions over time.

Seeking clarification from MCF

Please go to the train the trainers piece here and read the comments. Thank you reader. Can we have clarification from Greg please? Your credibility is on the line. First GM Chess Academy trainers have attended the course and paid good money on the understanding that the course is conducted by MCF. If this is untrue then it may constitute fraud.

More on fighting spirit

I talked about Li Tian's fighting spirit. And I inferred that without it we will not have our own GM. Mark was not so lucky. I was not sufficiently aware his first 2 years. By the time I realised, the damage was done. But kids are resilient. I believe he will bounce back with my full support.

We need many Tigers to struggle with each other in healthy competition to bring out the first GM.

In order for them to do this every stake holder need to play their role. At the train the trainers course for instance, I see PICA already taking steps to control the trainers in Perak by forming a committee of trainers. Why? They are not the certifying body. They themselves have no clue on training. Is this helpful? Or will this lead to more politics? MCF needs to be more discerning. What actions and policies move us to our goal and what actions do not.

Any action that can lead to the reduction or destruction of the fighting spirit of our players are wrong policies.

So what can we do? We cannot stop them from forming those committees. True. But we do not have to support them. MCF does not need to support such actions. Then we will have direction.

Suspect tournaments do this to our players. They rob the players of the ability to gain glory by their own efforts. Someone else can take it away from them. Will they continue to fight, if someone else less deserving wins by nefarious means? Is the lesson here to them that they must suck up to the organisers or they will lose. Look very closely what happens; What happens to their fighting spirit when they do that? Is there any point to training? Lets instead learn how to suck up properly. GM class sucking up. Is that what we want for our children/players? To suck up to small people or they get victimised? Note: I am not asking them to be rude. In fact gentlemanly behaviour is part of their development.

So what can we do? We do not organise. We do have power you know. We can stop supporting such tournaments. Yes, simply not go. We can support the organisers that run good tournaments. There are many now. Then we have direction.

Something happened at World Youth.

I am informed that during the world youth, the parents grouped together and told MCF that they will not pay for an MCF official to go to Turkey. And MCF backed down. They nominated a parent who was there as their representative. So we can effect change if we have the courage to work together.

Another important point is the message to our children. If the adults stand for what is right, they too will learn fighting spirit from us. If they see us meek and accepting of abuses, that is what they will learn too. They will have learned helplessness from us.

I dont think we can continue to look the other way if we are serious about finding that first GM. I don't think we can afford to support indiscriminately wrong policies, abusive officials. Why? Because they undo the work we have done. For every step we take forward they move us back. For every child we build, they tear down. Is that why we have had no movement for 40 years? No results. Our National juniors now are nowhere near where they should be in terms of Fide rating, relatively, even compared to our own past.

So Greg, you have the helm now. Don't keep us spinning our wheels again. I hope you wont let us down. For others we can take affirmative action. We are not helpless unless we choose to be.

This is not about us. It is about the players. They are the ones who compete, who sweat it out. We are only meant to support that effort.

Wednesday, March 3, 2010

More from IM Jimmy Liew

In his series IM Jimmy Liew talks about the structure of MCF as well as the experiences of senior Malaysian players. A must read. Please note that I have never discussed anything or collaborated with Jimmy in anyway. We have met a few times in tournaments but have never been introduced. Click here

What are dramas?

Dramas are depicted by the type of behaviours that keep us spinning our wheels. They keep us on the same spot no matter how much energy is poured into the effort.

To see through dramas and to get results and movement we need to understand a few things and get rid of a few old assumptions. We need clarity on the role of Associations, of private initiatives like Academies. We need clarity on the role of tournaments and the role of development via training and coaching. In coaching I talk about goal setting for individual players that are determined in tournaments etc. See this article.

We need to see clearly our roles as parents, players, bloggers and all other stake holders like sponsors etc.

If we are not clear then Associations can be used to make money, accounts are hidden, no proper criteria can be set because it now goes against private money making initiatives within Associations. When I was in PICA, I argued that I have nothing against making money but it must be done outside the Association. Start an Academy I said. We need those. But an Association is an NGO. It is not meant for money making.

It is a fallacy that money should not be made from chess. We need top trainers and top coaches. And we need money to train them and pay them.

But an Association is not the place. Besides where would the money go? Not towards development I think. Associations, in my opinion, are meant to create guidelines, set criteria and to hold State and National tournaments, if they are able to, etc.

So I think officials should be chosen that are financially independent. But if this is not possible then proper rules against conflict of interests need to be established.

Or the drama continues. And so long as it continues we will not get a genuine GM in Malaysia. We will keep spinning our wheels.

Tuesday, March 2, 2010

We need to think deeper- Goal setting

There is a flurry of activity in chess today. This is fantastic but we need to look deeper. We need to see where we want to go and how to get there. I have stated in a round about way that we need direction. Basically it means the horses pull together.

I have said that values are important, partnerships are important. That it is important to build trust amongst partners. Sabotage, back stabbing, character assasination within our community is not helpful.

Let me put it another way. In physics effort must be followed by movement or no work is done. Let me give you an example. After Mark got advice and videos from Sumant, he did a lot of "work" and felt his game had improved. So I took him to Limau Bali (our local chess haunt) and he got thrashed. So I told him no work was done. Sound harsh? Or reality?

When we set goals, it must be measurable. Say we aim for 5 FM's in 2 years and we reach it. That is measurable. From the Fm's will come more IM's and then eventually a GM is born. Then we need to look at what it takes to produce those 5 FM's and pour our efforts into it. If one FM only is produced then there was some work done. Then we need to examine what went wrong with our plan. Then we try and do it better, focus our energies better, find the flaws in our strategy etc.

So it is not only about activity. It's about directed activity. It's about values, partnerships with trust or this cant be done. We'll just end up chasing our own tails as we have done for a long time. We keep looking for the short cuts. Is there any that are genuine?

So after this flurry, will any work be done?

One day in the life....Penultimate.article

Please see the rest of the series here. Intro, Part 1, Part 2, Part 3.

I am going to reveal here the events surrounding the Syuen Tournament. I am now able to do so because I am no longer a committee member and under no moral obligation to the team. And I will do this by way of the letter to MCF outlining the case.

My reasons for doing this are 3 fold.

1. The manner decisions are reached in Associations are a mystery to most. I have been in chess for 6 years now and only from my short stay in PICA did I manage to catch a glimpse of the internal politics. I think it is important for members of Associations to know what they are voting for.

2. This is also a poser to MCF to see if they feel they have a moral obligation to ensure that the elected officials of their affiliates are treated fairly and in accordance to the Consitution. Or if it's just a decorative piece of paper? Whether they believe that they have an obligation to address the excesses of their affiliates? MCF's response will tell us much about what they think is important for the development of chess. Whether if the rules only apply to players and selections or if they apply to the affiliates/officials themselves? I have officially written to MCF when I was still in the committee and the ball is now in their court.

3. In a manner of speaking this will also be an attempt to clear my name as I have been sacked as a committee member without a hearing and without due process. And to compound the matter I have also been removed as a member of PICA which now casts aspersions on my integrity. Currently this blog remains my only voice as my rights as well as the rights of every member who voted for me have been taken away. Someone once said, if they believe, no proof is necessary and if they don't, no amount of proof will suffice. Lets put this to the test.

Note: This blog and it's "revelations" started much after the events stated and so should not be confused for to the reasons why the behaviour mentioned ocurred. I have also mentioned names here for reasons of clarity as I see no need to protect their identity in view of their attack on my person.

I will try to conclude the series in my last part so you may share my perspective.

ps: Please excuse my ramblings in the preamble of my email to MCF. There was and still continues to be much confusion about what model is permissible given the status of PICA as an NGO. This is much clearer now with the successful launch of the DATCC model. Strangely this model was "rejected" by PICA when I proposed it although I understand they were acting under advicement from the initiators of DATCC. And we now see DATCC working in tandem with PICA. You'll get better clarity just looking at the sequence of events. But if you are interested in the convoluted logic to Association politics, the preamble can shed some light.

My email to MCF here. This email was sent before I was officially informed by letter of my sacking. At that time Greg told me there was nothing he could do until the official letter came. I am still waiting for an official response from MCF.