Friday, March 8, 2013

Reminder.

Here.

It is very important that those with the legal authority to settle the issue of the accounts, which is the state Affiliates, makes those decisions. If the decisions are made by those without the authority ie the recently inflated, previous ROS committee, then this issue can be challenged again and this saga may not end.

All my best to Malaysian chess. May Monday be the new dawn where we will truly begin the fight back to bringing Malaysian chess back into the International arena where we belong, with our heads held high.

Thursday, March 7, 2013

The 2 possible futures for Malaysian chess.


There is the general wisdom that there is no place for politics in sports and I can't agree more. Politics in any form is destructive for that sport. Let me try to see if I can explain it this way. Chess is chess and the more time you spend on understanding the different aspects of the game the better your chess becomes.

What happens when the back door comes in is that players start to focus on tai chi, nail bending and fat numbers. Why? That is simply the way to get to represent the Country with only minimal chess. This way you can bypass selection via a PR campaign with collusion from within MCF. If anyone questions, then you first try tai chi, if that doesn't work you do a nail bending or shouting exercise. Ref: Here. If all fails you ban.

So lets work out the percentages here. To get as good as Jimmy and Peter can we say that they need to spend at least 70% of their time working on those back door techniques? So what happens to their chess?

Look, those are players from before the internet. Those days as told to me by strong coaches, all you need was a secret latest book on chess that nobody else has and you can be king. Today is a different world. Today the knowledge abounds everywhere on the net. It has become a game of who can learn and then who can learn faster.

Jimmy and Peter have long lost their edge and is now spending almost all of their time making sure no one can take their places on the senior squad via the back doors. To our shame they seem to have supporters from inside MCF aiding them. And Peter himself is still trying for that last ditch attempt into MCF. It's do or die.

And so that is the politics.

On the other hand we can have this future. You have heard me describe Mal/Sing 2011. You heard me tell the stories of how many parents worked together to motivate the players to go all out to win after trailing very badly on the first day. There was no race or politics. We were team Malaysia apart from yet another sad incident caused by Peter. Despite that we prevailed and we won the day. On the train journey back you should see the spirit onboard. Kids that I have rarely heard speak were talking animatedly. Parents shared openly. There were no Malays, Chinese or Indians on that train. Only Malaysians that struggled and worked together to achieve victory for our Nation.

That is the glimpse of another future that we have the opportunity to create from this coming AGM.

But the train arrived in KL and then we read the stories on Jimmy's blog saying our victory was a sham. And we all came back down to earth. Back to the politics in our chess.

We can reject that "Vision" of Peter, Jimmy and their supporters in MCF at the AGM who say our Juniors are lousy. We can believe that we have the players that can succeed in International chess if they don't get knocked out here by the politics.

So we can have 2 possible futures. One is where we have the chance to repeat the Mal/Sing experience and the other is where we go back to talking and whispering in corridors afraid that we will be seen talking together and then our children victimised.

Which future we will have is now in the hands of the State delegates at the AGM this Sunday.

In the meantime Mark and I will be travelling tomorrow to play chess at USM Penang where we are keen to try out new ideas on the board in preparation for NC and NJ this year. See you guys there.

The Serenity prayer.


God, grant me the serenity
To accept the things I cannot change;
Courage to change the things I can;
And wisdom to know the difference.

Wednesday, March 6, 2013

Presidential race- A FGM Commentary Pt. 2


The latest feedback is that Peter has pulled out of the direct race and is now looking for a deal just for entry into MCF after realising that he will have zero support apart from himself. Questions were raised about how his KL Open is faring compared to other tournaments in the region like the upcoming HD tournament in Vietnam and Bangkok Open. Both events are drawing huge crowds while KL Open seems to be getting smaller and smaller with negligible local support. And he wants to take over MCF and make it in his image. Delusional. Peter's old sins are catching up with him and he now realises that nobody supports or wants to deal with him despite all his offerings. So will he succeed in getting a back door deal when anyone associated with him will carry a serious liability? Well we'll know Sunday when it has to all come out.

But what is wrong with that picture? Personally I think it is just wheeling and dealing for posts but without thinking about what is best for Malaysian chess or what they are able to contribute. How about we look at the tasks that needs to be done and then finding the right people for the right posts so that MCF has all the skill sets to take us forward?

So I hope we can do this without anger and with the intention to build and not getting revenge etc. If we are successful then we can leave the failure behind and move forward. Isn't that better? If there are future injustices then at least we will have an MCF that can fairly judge for all within the chess community.

I argued here that we should be lenient to Greg because whatever has been said and done he does have good organising abilities that will be hard to replace. In a company his position will be akin to a COO (Chief Operating Officer). His job will be to run things around the Country according to the Vision of the President and the policies set by the AGM and the committee. So while important his job is NOT at the highest decision making position.

So lets look at the position of the President. I have heard people say that he must be able to bring in money and sponsorship. I disagree. That is a bonus but that is not absolutely necessary. Actually many people can bring in sponsors and that should be encouraged. The problem Malaysian chess faces is that many sponsorships are sabotaged.

So I feel the key factor we need in the President is the ability to direct correct action so that Malaysian chess is a conducive place for investors and players alike. It is my believe that Malaysian Chess has fallen to the terrible low we are in today where we have a 2100 IM attacking anyone and sundry and a 1900 FM looking to take over National Chess is because no rules have been enforceable. MCF just looks away from the abuses and is itself party to a fraudulent selection amongst other accusations levied against it.

Having one of our key tournaments questioned by players as to having had suspect pairings etc and having nothing done is also very damaging to our reputation as a good destination for chess by International players. All these things including a good development program so that real chess players can advance as opposed to back door dealers is crucial to our future success.

And all that conducting is done by the President. He directs what needs attention and what can be ignored. He also directs the Secretary.

That is the key crucial position. As I said I am not partisan. So I suggest that the State delegates debate the issues first before election of officials. Then ask the people who are vying for the position of President how they propose those issues can be solved when they get into power. From there the delegates will be in a better position to see which candidate really cares about developing Malaysian chess and which one wants the position from a deal but have no interest in our development.

A cautionary note. I was talking to the President of a State Association recently and he expressed his interest in developing his State first. I think we need to look at this in another way. A good MCF will do far more to develop the State than anything the State can do by themselves. Look at the current situation. What can you do if the national policy is to get their fingers on the pie? So this has to be stopped at source. In fact I suggest that the States offer their very best people on the MCF committee to support a President that wants to develop Malaysian chess. He cannot do it on his own and he cannot rely on the many deadwood in the current committee. I hear some of them have not even opened their mouth in MCF committee meetings to contribute or otherwise in years. So why stay on?

Please think about this and we can have an AGM where we will emerge with a chess structure which says we are back and we mean business and that truly says Malaysia Boleh.

Presidential race- A FGM Commentary. Pt 1


Before I talk about all the latest going ons and offer some suggestions, I have been informed that certain people are going around saying that I am backing Zuhri's candidacy and that I will be appointed the new Secretary of MCF.

Let me try again to make my stand clear. I am not for or against anyone. I am only for improvement and correcting the flaws in our system. So I am for the candidate who will offer us solutions. 

Why I write my blog is simply because I do not feel it is correct for both MCF and Jimmy to sabotage the training of the Juniors by a current and fighting GM for Asean 2010. I do not think it is correct for Jimmy to attack the players who came to my house to train for SEA games selection 2011. FGM is a legally registered chess academy and any player can come or leave without intimidation. If my training is not any good, they can leave but I want to be judged on merit and by the market, not by gangsters. And so my intention is to restart my academy if there is change in MCF and I know that my projects, sponsors won't be sabotaged or attacked. When I know that the players that choose to come to me won't be sabotaged and attacked.

That there is an MCF that will act fairly when such incidences occur. That is all. I do not seek position or power. I only seek to be allowed to do the work I enjoy without hindrance from thugs. Is that clear now?

I also seek a level playing field so that if my players or any other players from any other academy or trainer/coach is any good they too will be given the chance to represent the Country via a fair selection process. 

No more fraudulent selections and back doors. If Jimmy still wants to play for the Country then join in the selection like everyone else. His performance at the Olympiad was very disappointing and so he does not deserve any pre-selection. If Peter wants to go to SEA games then play in the selection if he dares. Nobody is seeking to ban him or Jimmy, disgrace though they are. If Li Tian wants to be the strongest Junior then do it on the board. Win at National Junior. This is chess. It is not about who tells the tallest story or has the fattest numbers. It is not a nail bending, tai chi or marketing contest. Simple right?

Every coach, trainer, organiser, player or State official deserves an unbiased MCF to rule properly when an injustice has been done. 

I know there is a lot of anger around but I hope that we can approach these issues rationally and seek to build Malaysian chess. To destroy is easy but to build is not easy. So I hope that will be what this coming AGM will be about. The gangsters have ruled for too long. But it should also not be about retribution. If we do that then this will never end as I will try to argue next. More later.

Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Is this the reason why our system cannot produce strong players?


What we have seen so graphically displayed on Jimmy's blog is the attack on the Juniors when they trained to win selection for the last SEA games. And I have attempted to give the reasons here.

They are attacked very viciously and in a very public manner should they ever try to get into the senior squad. (Unless it is a sanctioned young U15 of course. And we know that game too don't we? Here.)

I have attempted in my blog to say that this type of attacks on our children when they are still young, cripples their chess for the lesson Jimmy inputs into their minds is the association of deep pain with any attempts to beat the seniors. And this attack is a lot more damaging when it comes from someone who is supposedly from their own team as opposed to psychological attacks from their opponents overseas.

And then we know that MCF only supports age group events till around U16 in the main and occasionally U18. But at the U20 level they are sent out one at a time, if at all, to be slaughtered overseas. And then they are made fun of by people like Peter and Jimmy who will lose no time to publicize their lack of success overseas as if this will make them look like stronger players by comparison.

We can see that the chips are heavily stacked against the Juniors to ever supplant the seniors no matter what the true level of their chess is. So let us look at what the real level of some of those seniors really are in order to understand why they need to attack children. We now know that fat numbers don't count right? It can simply be manufactured. Every chess player knows this. Just play in tournaments where you know that most of the players are weaker than you. Then you can accumulate lots of fat numbers over time. But does that mean you are strong relative to real chess players overseas or those who plays in tough open tournaments but have smaller numbers?

Lets look at the performance of Jimmy at the Olympiads. We can thank the internet for that. Today we can follow their games. The actual level of Jimmy's fighting strength is around that of the real players in the band of Fide rating that can stop him. And he was stopped at around 2100 plus. Lets be generous. Lets say the higher 2100s. And if he is at that level lets also guess where Peter is. Can we say 2000 or maybe even 1900? Hard to tell. He doesn't dare to play anymore. Today he just practices bending nails and shouting.

So that is our current reality. The question now is how did we get so bad?

Ok. Let me show you the comparison of a neighbouring Country. Lets look at their Junior program first. Their National Juniors are endorced by their Federation and given letters to help them to secure sponsorship. If they cannot get it the Federation then comes in to help. If they play overseas under sponsorship and they don't do well, they are recalled and asked to prove themselves in local tournaments before they are allowed to go out again. Now this is very very important for the development of the players. Juniors or Seniors. They go out and fight and the Federation supports by helping them secure sponsorship. And if they don't do well then they are recalled for repairs at home. Ergo, there is respect for the hard earned money of the sponsors.

Lets now ask another very simple question here. Why can't we do that for our own Malaysian players? This is my view. MCF does not like to give out letters because they want the sponsors money to be banked into their account. Letters are given out but usually after a lot of arguing and then arrive late (so you won't have enough time to get sponsors yourself?) but they will always try to get the money into their account rather than directly to the players. The question is why?

I postulate that the driving intention is to try to get their hands on the money. I have heard of a case where the sponsor paid to MCF and the player was not allowed to go and the money was not returned to the sponsor. Does this sound familiar? Here.

Can you see the systemic effect of when the Secretary is not paid and he has insufficient independent income? My assertion is that this one factor eventually leads to the situation we see currently. The players feel cheated after all their sacrifice and in return they try to make sure that no one else succeeds. Is that plausible?

And so the system now perpetuates itself. And now we have weak players all round because of this. Why can't we support the players who dare to fight and improve their chess? Why try to destroy them psychologically and if that doesn't succeed, try to ban them when they are a threat to the seniors? What have they done to you personally? If the seniors have a problem and can still play fighting chess today then they need to take it up with the leadership of MCF. Past and Present. Not take it out on the Juniors.

So this needs to change before we can build strong players in Malaysia. Otherwise we can shout Malaysia boleh till we are all hoarse or say we want this person or that person to be GM but it won't happen unless these issues are dealt with first.

Monday, March 4, 2013

Representing the Country and the Fide handbook.


Note: The stories below are very slightly exaggerated to help demonstrate a point.

Say you are watching a selection to represent the Country and one of the players is already in front of the table and the other one is just outside the hall but within view. For ease of description let's call him Sifu Peter. Sifu Peter stops just outside and takes out a 6 inch nail and proceeds to bend it with his teeth. Then he smashes the 6 bricks he brought with him just by shouting before entering the hall and taking his place. The game starts and Sifu Peter wins his game. Has anything wrong been done?

Actually no. Look up your Fide handbook. It doesn't say anything about not bending 6 inch nails with your teeth etc. If you win on the chess board you win the selection to represent the Country. This is chess. It's a mind sport. If the other player was so awed by the demonstration that his mind crashed and he lost, then he is just not mentally strong enough to play for the Country yet. So Sifu Peter won fair and square. Maybe?

At the other selection game another thing happens outside the hall. Lets call this player Sifu Jimmy. At the entrance Sifu Jimmy demonstrates some Tai Chi and knocks 10 chess player spectators off their feet without ever touching them and then enters the hall and wins his game. Nothing wrong done right? Chess is a mind game. Check the Fide handbook. Nothing is said about Tai Chi.

So what is my point? My point is that this is about chess. Win or loss is only determined by the Fide handbook.

But the win must always be registered on the chess board by Fide rules. All else doesnt count. Those are just the preripheral mind tricks.

So you are allowed to do whatever you want without breaking the law of the land or the organiser's conditions and still win the selection. If nail bending or Tai Chi helps you win on the board then that was the correct strategy applied by the Sifu's.

My opinion is that it only has limited application. It probably won't work overseas against other Sifu's who plays real chess and is mentally strong from playing tough tournaments.

But you can promote anything you want for your chess school. You can do marketing exercises via fat numbers tournaments, promote certain select "demonstration" games, gangster looks, humble looks etc. Nothing wrong there. Those things are not covered in the Fide handbook. This is about chess. Win on the board and you win the selection. Yes?

So in the same way, you can promote mental strength, tough training and competitor analysis. Nothing wrong there too. It doesn't say on the Fide handbook that you cannot do that.

So the players can choose. Those who don't like bending nails with their teeth or Tai Chi can go to someone else. Some may not like tough training so they choose the gangster look training. Some get tired of practising staring in the mirror for long hours to get the perfect gangster look and choose competitor analysis. Some may even prefer the humble look and go to Chin Seng for classes. Nothing wrong there too. Humble looks or cute looks is not covered by the Fide handbook either. But if you win in chess then you win the selection, yes?

Now lets go back to the Olympiad selection. So they entered Li Tian amidst great fanfare. With the music blaring loud he enters the hall to play chess. His opponents know that he has been taught by many masters. He has fat numbers and he has the protection of the nail bending and tai chi masters. He has a heavy marketing machinery behind him and just completed his "demonstration" games where the picture presented is that he eats super GM's for breakfast. He also attended some humility classes taught by Chin Seng as an extra weapon just in case. And he is also cute.

Then he sits down and is "bungkused" by Roshan, Eng Chiam and Syazwan. Now this is chess. Your training shows on the board. The rest is not relevant.

We all know that representing the Country is more than just the honour. It is also about exposure and the lessons gained from playing tough opponents overseas.

Now my question is this. Has something wrong been done when it is Li Tian who represented the Country at the Olympiads and not Eng Chiam and Syazwan?  They won in chess against all the mind games hurled at them. They kept their minds strong and they did the business of playing chess. So who won the mind game contest and who won in chess? I think the answer is obvious. Those boys won both. And so they have now been robbed of both the honour AND the exposure of playing in the Olympiads.

Selection should only be based on chess. And I submit that the considerations of mental strength and good competitor analysis has much more basis to chess than the other offerings of tai chi and nail bending etc. That is my sincere opinion. The rest don't work overseas.

Something is seriously wrong when MCF send the marketers and gangster look people etc to represent Malaysia in chess.

What is really against the Fide handbook is match fixing, playing with the pairings, illegal bannings etc. And we need to be much more vigilant about this.

Something is seriously wrong when MCF does not want to look into this despite many genuine allegations.

We need to be clear on this before we get to the AGM or we will not be able to set out in the correct direction to bring Malaysian chess to the next level and get our own GM. Chess is chess. Our real chess players cannot continue to be knocked out this way.

If you think gangster look or Tai Chi is the way by all means go the Sifu Jimmy etc. Nobody is stopping you. And if it's a marketing contest, nail bending contest, humility contest etc, fine, you'll probably do well with those masters. Not all players can take tough training in chess. I will even recommend the services of Peter, Jimmy or Chin Seng if I think they provide the services that the players are looking for.

But Malaysia is not sending out marketing experts, tai chi experts, humility experts etc to represent the Country. Malaysia is entering the players in a chess tournament.

And so it should have been Eng Chiam and Syazwan and the other players who were at selection that should have qualified. If certain players feel that selection is not important, then they do not deserve to play for Malaysia. As we know, even one year away from tough competition will blunt your game.

So State Affiliates, you need to get the selection criteria clear at the AGM. It is in your interest to do so. Otherwise what will happen to the strong players from your State? Your strong chess player's places will be taken by people with only gangster looks, tai chi, is very humble or cute etc but not have strong chess.

Bring this up at the AGM and then you will be clear on who to vote for the President. See past the mind games, get to the meat of the issues and then Malaysian chess will be strong again. At the AGM it is about the constitution. For Malaysian chess to win, the win must come from the chess board of the AGM. 

So it is up to you now. You are the players in this game.

Thank you for your time.

Saturday, March 2, 2013

Presidential race.

Looks like things are heating up and new deals and tricks are being thought up in panic as they begin to realise that they might lose.  Here.

Friday, March 1, 2013

Accounts, the other half of the story. Part 2.


First half of the story. Here. The other half. Part 1. Here.

Right now when I mention Greg's name I get responses like arrogant, biadap etc. So no one remembers about the issue of the salary. Anger rules the day. So I am going to tell my little story again here. I am not defending his bad behaviour or asking you to vote for him. That decision is up to you. All I am asking for is a balanced judgement based on the full picture. I am sure that is the way you would like to be judged too if it were you on the dock.

Remember, I too was an official for a little time. And I can tell you that it is not an easy job. I too tried to put in selection in PICA. I was the chair but I was not responsible for the list of names presented for consideration. I merely facilitated the discussions. But directly after the decision a member of the selection committee phoned up a parent and said that I was responsible for removing his son's name. Actually his son was never on the list presented for deliberation. And that parent called me up in the middle of the night and shouted at me. That was my initiation rite into the politics of chess officialdom.

I was the team manager for the Perak Team and a parent with 2 players on the Team insisted that his children played to a different strategy than what we had determined together as players and manager. He threatened to pull his children out of the Team half way in the Tournament if he did not get his way.

I introduced a potential sponsor from a public listed company who had RM2 million of sponsorship fund and was interested to sponsor chess. At the meeting Dato Tan and the other PICA committee members were invited to attend. A few days later I was sacked without any grounds.

What I am saying here is that it is very difficult to function in chess as an official. The attacks can come out of thin air. So you need someone very skilled to get anything done. And we have put Greg into this situation without even the means to defend himself. No salary or sufficient independent income. So he lost his temper a few times. How would you have fared in this situation? In my mind his occasional loss of temper and misjudgement is understandable from the viewpoint of the constant strain he is under dealing with many many more issues on a National scale. Much much more than what I faced in PICA at that time I am sure.

So I feel it may be too soon to judge him. Personally I would like to give him another chance but with a decent salary to see if he can do a better job. But that is me. You may not feel the same. But at least consider the full picture.

Consider also the guy who wants to replace him. He cannot even run one State Association. What has he done for KL? He cannot even manage to run one tournament without breaking down, shouting and insulting parents and players. And he is at best a very mediocre trainer and I am very sure cannot even play strong chess today. So what possible use is he at MCF level? And even worse, he has no respect for rules. He even bans players without any grounds. Everything is personal to him. He even gives no thought to demoralising an entire Malaysian contingent of players in order to flex his ego.

So I hope you will consider all these things at the AGM when the accounts is brought up. Are we for development and for the betterment of Malaysian chess or will we also make decisions based on petty or selfish considerations.

Thank you for your time and for allowing me the chance to present my thoughts.

Today's contemplation.


You cannot solve a problem from the same consciousness that created it. You must learn to see the world anew.

   --  Albert Einstein



Not out of right practice comes right thinking, but out of right thinking comes right practice. It matters enormously what you think. If you think falsely, you will act mistakenly; if you think selfishly, your conduct will suit your thinking.

   --  Annie Besant